The Sports Card Shop · Listings

(219) 615-9206 info@thesportscardshop.com

New Buffalo, MI • Valparaiso, IN

The Sports Card Shop

Home Shop

Collections

Live

Community

Events Visit Us Sell Your Collection

The Sports Card Shop

Your local card shop with a global reach. Serving collectors from New Buffalo, MI and Valparaiso, IN since day one.

Our Locations

New Buffalo, MI

18853 US Hwy 12
New Buffalo, MI 49117

Valparaiso, IN

118 Lincolnway
Valparaiso, IN 46383

(219) 615-9206 info@thesportscardshop.com

Shop

All Cards
Live Breaks
Sell Your Collection
Sell With Us

Info

Visit Us
Terms of Service
Privacy Policy

© 2026 The Sports Card Shop. All rights reserved.

Powered by District

info@thesportscardshop.com

The Sports Card Shop

info@thesportscardshop.com

Sell Your Collection

Terms of Service

Rookie Cards

Search
Free Shipping

No listings found

Try adjusting your filters or search query.

Search
Free Shipping